WATCH: Michael Missaghie of Arch Corporation shares 3 high-conviction real estate investments for 2025: He explains what makes BSR REIT (HOM.U) undervalued, why Chartwell (CSH.UN) could be a prime target, and why Brookdale (BKD) might offer explosive upside if demographic tailwinds persist. All three are positioned for strong cash flow, favorable demographic trends and possibly, takeover interest.
Pro Picks is brought to you by ATB Financial. With $62 billion in assets, ATB Financial is powering possibilities for more than 820,000 financial services clients in Alberta and beyond. ATB’s Capital Markets arm is a full-service investment dealer that offers investment and corporate banking, sales and trading, institutional research, and risk management. Visit www.ATB.com/inthemoney for more information.
1. BSR REIT (TSX: HOM.U) – U.S. Sunbelt Residential REIT
- Why It’s a Compelling Buy:
BSR REIT is capitalizing on robust demand in the U.S. Sunbelt, particularly Texas, with rising occupancy and cash flows signaling strong property performance. Despite a recent sale of 10 assets to Avalon Bay at full IFRS NAV, the stock trades at a 20-25% discount to its net asset value, offering a clear value opportunity. The elimination of complex Class B shares has streamlined its structure, making it more attractive to investors seeking exposure to high-growth markets. - Why It’s a Takeout Candidate:
The removal of Class B shares has cleared previous M&A hurdles, positioning BSR as a prime target for larger REITs or institutional investors eyeing the Sunbelt’s rental boom. The Avalon Bay transaction underscores market interest in its high-quality portfolio. With REIT M&A expected to accelerate, BSR’s assets and valuation make it a strong candidate for a buyout. - Upside Potential:
Trading at approximately $13 per share, BSR has a consensus price target of $16, suggesting a 23% gain. Closing the NAV discount or a takeout at NAV could push the stock to $16.25-$17.50, delivering 25%+ returns. In a rising M&A environment, a premium deal could yield even higher gains.
2. Chartwell Retirement Residences (TSX: CSH.UN) – Canadian Seniors Housing REIT
- Why It’s a Compelling Buy:
Chartwell is a leader in Canada’s seniors housing market, focusing on private-pay independent and assisted living properties. With new supply scarce and demographics driving demand, occupancy is climbing, and cash flows are projected to grow 15% by 2026, outpacing peers. Trading at a modest NAV premium, it remains undervalued compared to U.S. peers like Welltower, which trade at 100% NAV premiums, offering growth at a reasonable price. - Why It’s a Takeout Candidate:
Chartwell’s widely held shareholder base and high-quality portfolio make it a top M&A target, particularly for pension plans or U.S. REITs seeking to expand in seniors housing. Missaghie highlights it as a prime candidate due to its strong growth profile and well-managed assets. The sector’s resilience and Chartwell’s operational strength position it for potential acquisition. - Upside Potential:
At an estimated $14-$15, Chartwell could see “dramatic” upside if acquired at U.S. peer valuations, potentially reaching $28-$30 for a 100%+ return. Organic growth alone supports 15-20% gains by 2026, driven by cash flow increases. An M&A event could significantly amplify returns, making it a standout pick.
3. Brookdale Senior Living (NYSE: BKD) U.S. Seniors Housing Operator
- Why It’s a Compelling Buy:
Brookdale is undergoing a turnaround in the U.S. seniors housing market, with a high-quality portfolio benefiting from tight supply and demographic trends. Rising occupancy and improving cash flows signal operational strength, yet the stock trades at a significant NAV discount, offering value. Past activist pressure has kept management focused on creating value, adding a catalyst for performance. - Why It’s a Takeout Candidate:
Brookdale’s NAV discount and improving fundamentals make it an attractive target for private equity or larger REITs looking to capitalize on the seniors housing boom. Although earlier activism faded, the board remains incentivized to address underperformance relative to peers, increasing M&A likelihood. The sector’s growth trajectory enhances its appeal to strategic buyers. - Upside Potential:
Trading at roughly $7-$8, Brookdale could reach $9-$11 conservatively, a 25-50% gain, driven by operational improvements. In a stronger scenario with robust occupancy or an M&A deal, it could hit $13-$15, offering 60-100% upside. A takeout at peer valuations could push returns even higher, aligning with sector M&A trends.
