A year ago, Adam Waterous was fighting two battles: one for MEG Energy, and one for the future of the entire Canadian energy sector. He lost the bid for MEG — but he may be winning the bigger war. In this episode, he lays out a decade-defining thesis for why Canada is about to reposition itself on the world stage, where the trillion-dollar catch lies, and what it all means for investors deciding whether to show up.
With over $100 billion in assets, ATB Financial is powering possibilities for more than 843,000 financial services clients. ATB Cormark Capital Markets is a leading North American investment firm providing holistic corporate and capital markets advice and full-service financial solutions. Visit www.ATB.com/inthemoney for more information.
The Thesis: “Down Five, Up Five”
- The U.S. is set to lose roughly 5 million barrels a day over the next decade — from ~13M down to ~8M — as short-lived shale wells decline faster than they can be replaced.
- Canada is positioned to add roughly 5 million barrels a day, doubling production from 5M to 10M, as Ottawa and Alberta finally align on an “energy superpower” goal.
- The elegance of the setup: as the U.S. falls, Canada rises right next door. “I’d rather be generally correct than precisely wrong,” Waterous says of the timeline.
Looking to invest in high-quality companies without high fees? The HAMILTON CHAMPIONS™ suite of ETFs offers exposure to diversified portfolios of equity champions across tech, financials, utilities, and dividend strategies, all with a low 0.19% management fee, designed to help you stay invested with confidence for the long term. For more information on the HAMILTON CHAMPIONS™ suite, visit: www.hamiltonetfs.com/hamilton-
A NAFTA-Sized Economic Prize
- Every 1 million barrels a day of new production adds about $21 billion a year to Canada’s GDP — roughly 0.8% of growth.
- Scale that to 5 million barrels a day and you’re looking at $100 billion-plus per year in incremental GDP, or about 4% growth.
- The only comparable event in the last 50 years, Waterous argues, is the NAFTA free-trade deal — a shift that shaped the Canadian economy for the following 40 years.
Canada vs. Saudi Arabia
- At 10 million barrels a day, Canada would be arm-wrestling Saudi Arabia for the title of world’s largest oil producer — while the U.S. and Russia both slide toward ~8M.
- “No one’s going to describe us as a middle power,” Waterous says of a Canada sitting at the very top of global production.
- Oil, he argues, is Canada’s only real economic “hard power” against the United States — and could ultimately win us “the best trade deal of any country in the world.”
The Vibe Shift in Ottawa
- The math on energy’s upside hasn’t changed in a decade — what changed is that Ottawa is finally listening. Waterous credits both PM Carney and Premier Smith for the alignment.
- Two government-backed pipeline proposals are now on the table — a striking reversal from the hostile climate of just a year ago.
- But there’s a catch buried in how the West Coast pipeline is being built — and in who ends up footing the bill.
The Pipeline Bill Taxpayers Don’t See
- Because Ottawa won’t touch the regulations (C-69, C-48, the industrial carbon tax), the private sector won’t build — so the government is building the West Coast line itself.
- A privately built line might run ~$15 billion; the public version is now pegged closer to $43 billion, leaving Ottawa to effectively absorb ~$25 billion in extra cost (plus another $10 billion for the Vancouver port).
- The result: a projected ~5% return for the federal government versus ~12% for a private builder. “We’re doing the right thing,” Waterous says, “but maybe not in the most efficient way possible.”
The Carbon Tax Catch-22
- The carbon tax on existing production jumped 6.5x. Waterous likens it to your property tax leaping from $10,000 to $65,000 overnight — so what happens to the value of the asset? It drops.
- Ottawa built the pipeline; now the pressure shifts to Alberta to offer royalty incentives compelling enough to convince producers to actually fill it.
- That incentive framework is the real swing factor for the whole plan — and it hasn’t been announced yet.
Don’t miss our next episode in the innovation series!
