Canada has no shortage of breakthrough ideas. The problem, Jim Balsillie argues, is that too many of them create jobs, wealth and prosperity somewhere else. He even describes Canada as a “global philanthropist”—a country that invents world-changing technologies but lets the economic benefits accrue elsewhere. As Canada prepares to host the Prime Minister’s first-ever Canada Investment Summit this September, we’re kicking off our special summer series, Can Canada Meet the Moment?, with one of the country’s most influential voices on innovation.
With over $100 billion in assets, ATB Financial is powering possibilities for more than 843,000 financial services clients. ATB Cormark Capital Markets is a leading North American investment firm providing holistic corporate and capital markets advice and full-service financial solutions. Visit www.ATB.com/inthemoney for more information.
Bay Street vs. Wall Street: Two Very Different Mindsets
- Canadian investors tried to “hold you down”; American investors wanted “a piece of you and then 10x you.” That, he says, is “very liberating.”
- The lesson was hard-earned: a co-lead on BlackBerry’s IPO slapped a “hold” rating on the stock just three weeks after listing, with no material events — a power move to “knock us down.”
- His takeaway: be formidable and protect the organization, because “not everybody wishes you the best.”
It’s “100% Policy” — Maybe More
- Asked whether Canada’s shrinking startup pipeline is about policy or capital, Balsillie is emphatic: “100% policy. If it could be higher than 100% I would make it 100%.”
- Capital isn’t the problem — he raised nearly a billion dollars in a week for RIM in 2001. Money flows to good business plans, wherever they are.
- Companies, technology and money move freely across the border, so founders make the rational call and relocate to a “much more favorable” environment like Michigan or New York.
Looking to invest in high-quality companies without high fees? The HAMILTON CHAMPIONS™ suite of ETFs offers exposure to diversified portfolios of equity champions across tech, financials, utilities, and dividend strategies, all with a low 0.19% management fee, designed to help you stay invested with confidence for the long term. For more information on the HAMILTON CHAMPIONS™ suite, visit: www.hamiltonetfs.com/hamilton-
Canada’s AI Strategy: “Lacks Expertise, Coherence, Focus, and Leverage”
- He read the “AI for All” white paper and compared it to a bad cook throwing spices in a pot: “a laundry list of money and aspirations.”
- His core critique: the plan assumes adoption equals prosperity, but value chains decide who gets rich — “somebody’s going to get 100 billion and somebody’s going to get stake knives.”
- Instead of more money, he argues Canada needs a genuine reorientation — expertise, faster curriculum, and a real governance layer for things like health data.
Giving Away Our Best Ideas
- Canada invented foundational AI IP in Edmonton, Montreal and Toronto — and “absolutely squandered” it while the economic value accrued south of the border.
- It’s a repeat pattern: insulin at U of T, mRNA work at UBC, Tesla battery tech, Huawei technology out of Waterloo — taxpayer-funded breakthroughs that enriched others.
- “Owning the ideas is not the same as creating them” — and Canada keeps creating without owning, becoming, in his words, a “global philanthropist.”
AI, Jobs, and a Generation Sold Short
- Balsillie reads “prodigiously” on AI and admits it’s a hard problem: consequential for jobs, rising intergenerational inequity, and “bumpier before it gets better.”
- Unlike the smartphone era that young people embraced, Gen Z and Gen Alpha are pushing back — and “for good reasons,” as AI eats entry-level jobs and turns graduate degrees into “Uber taxis.”
- His prescription is stark: young people should have a bigger voice in architecting their future, and Canada may need to “reimagine” itself for a leverage-based world.
Why He Still Fights for Canada
- When companies leave, he refuses to call it a success — “It’s not a failure. It’s a loss,” because the prosperity and security accrue elsewhere.
- He rejects the “take my money and cut” attitude: walking away would let good people down and “the bullies win,” and he has “a problem with bullies.”
- Two-thirds of his day is spent growing tech in Canada. His hope: give good people the seat at the table they deserve — “that’s a life well-lived.”
Don’t miss the next installment of the innovation series!
